gentrification in west philadelphia
The name University City is the result of a University of Pennsylvania-supported marketing campaign. There is also gentrification in other parts of West Philadelphia. Initially, newcomers and old-time residents found common cause, coming together to fight the long-planned Cross Town Expressway that would have leveled South Street in an effort to attract suburban commuters back to the city. Business owners opened smaller boutiques, restaurants, and bars that catered to youthful adults who preferred to live within walking distance of dining and other diversions. East Mount Airy is a neighborhood in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania with a population of 21,236. From 1997 to 2007, the median price of a single-family home rose from $86,000 to $275,000. In the 1960s, sociologist Ruth Glass provided an evergreen definition of gentrification: when working class quarters have been invaded by the middle classuntil all or most of the working class occupiers are displaced and the whole social character of the district is changed., Gentrifications link to displacement is undeniable. Adams, Carolyn et al. The apartments were inexpensive for residents but they only provided basic housing and residents complained that the Housing Authority was not responsive to maintenance issues. One 1978 study estimated that real estate taxes in Queen Village had increased almost 300 percent since the start of the decade. Throughout the post-World War II period, Philadelphia struggled valiantly to entice the middle class back from the suburbs. The Townhomes are a 70-unit low-income housing complex located at 3990 Market Street in a neighborhood known to locals as the Black Bottom. Sandy Smith From 1982 to 1984, Philadelphia led the nation in the number of claims for such tax credits. More by Jared Ware. Its legacy as an epicenter of immigrant and African American life lent the area a desirable gloss of authenticitya dash of real folk in the city. Soon, real estate prices began to creep upwards. In this image from 1977, three children are looking through trash at one of Southwark Plaza's dilapidated playgrounds. [citation needed] Nicetown-Tioga saw a brief spurt of urban gentrification in the early to mid-2000s. (Photograph by Donald D. Groff for the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia.). The worlds fair idea was scrapped and on the national level, individual celebrations across the country were encouraged. This image from 1914 shows the Fish Market building, an enclosed warehouse that sold fresh fish from dozens of merchants. Constructed at Third and New Streets in 1902, in the 1920s Wilbur & Sons had to remove a section of the building to make room for construction of the Delaware River Bridge (later renamed the Benjamin Franklin Bridge). After World War II, suburbanization exploded. States must preserve public housing on the urban core, invest deeply in . Theres a magic in that. Its market value is listed as more than $9.5 million, according to the city's website. In order to combat the likelihood of gentrification increasing socioeconomic and racial segregation within cities, the authors note the need for policies like Philadelphia's recently implemented . Nobody had gotten vouchers; nobody was really able to get in contact with the relocation specialist. Attendees said that groups of residents are trying to fend off gentrification in West Philadelphia. In 1970, the neighborhood was nearly 50 percent Black. Housing activists, university students, and residents have staged protests and encampments to defend low-income housing in UC Townhomes, PHILADELPHIA, PA - APRIL 30: Protestors march over the death of Freddie Gray on April 30, 2015 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. As the nearby blocks of Queen Village saw large investments from city organizations to restore houses and raise property values, Southwark Plaza apartment buildings had broken elevators, limited electricity, and a trash-filled landscape. Developed alongside people on the frontlines of injustice, Prism will help deepen your understanding on the most pressing issues of our time. Typical buzzwords but the employees seem to demand that ownership be transferred to said queer BIPOC employees because of gentrification, reparations, and harm reduction, etc. Penns status as the largest employer in Philadelphia, its large endowment and the socioeconomic position of its students and staff complicates its existence in West Philadelphia. Along with other area institutions, it created the University City District, a nonprofit organization tasked with promoting development in the area. "The West Philadelphia Problem" asks listeners to problematize concepts like "safety" and "crime," and to interrogate the role academia has had in legitimizing these terms. Living in East Mount Airy offers residents an urban suburban mix feel and most residents own their homes. Inscription. . There were also cultural conflicts between old-timers and newcomers. This new fourstory building will have 21 apartment units, and Penn Family Medicine University City will move into the first floor office space from its building a few doors down at 4623 Spruce St. Ultimately, this partnership succeeded in defeating the proposed expressway. In 2013, there were still 4,000 buildings and over 10,000 lots sitting empty in Lower Northeast Philadelphia. While Temples administration tried to encourage better relations between students and residents, it did little to discourage the spread of private development around its campus. Instead, research from West Virginia University economist Zachary Porreca shows that when one urban WVU economist Zachary Porreca compared data on property values and shootings in Philadelphia and found that when one block gentrifies, drug crime migrates to neighboring blocks, escalati Eastwick is, as he says, super residential, replete with rowhomes and momandpop shops. That demonstrated to other residents that fighting back could be effective. Pei-designed modernist residential towers. In recent years, a number of Philadelphia neighborhoods have undergone significant transformation, with higher-income residents moving in, real estate prices rising, new businesses . After serving in the United States Navy during WWII, Bacon joined the Philadelphia City Planning Commission and became the executive director of the committee in 1949. For the city and real estate developers, it served as a hopeful model for neighborhood revitalization. Philip Gentry, a Lea School parent and member of the West Philly Coalition for Neighborhood Schools, said that he has seen some signs of potential gentrification occurring as a result of the funding granted to the Lea School. The city filled in Dock Creek in 1784 and paved the new land with stones, creating Dock Street. Even as Philadelphia experienced deindustrialization and decline in the 1970s, a handful of neighborhoods began to experience a phenomenon known as gentrificationa process where affluent individuals settled in lower-income areas. Revitalization efforts across the city included redeveloping older factories for new purposes. Even though Black residents fought gentrificationforming an anti-displacement group that demanded low-income housing optionstheir efforts were largely unsuccessful. New groups and institutions inundate an area and push out those who lived there before. San Francisco, it seems, is in a later stage of its gentrification timeline than Philadelphia. Dylan Gottlieb is a Ph.D. student at Princeton University, where he works on recent American urban history. The city had the power to seize land under eminent domainwhich allowed them to dice the community with the aim of making West Philly a satisfactory residential community and helping it to fulfill its potential as a center of private research.. From the Feds press release: the losses were especially acute in University City. Ira, explains it as, West Philadelphia experiences [loss of affordable housing] to a much greater extent because home values appreciate so much faster than income.. The area of the Dock Street Market in Society Hill was a place of commerce for more than two centuries before it was demolished in 1959 to allow construction of the residential Society Hill Towers. Its not a fight about lofty plans for the future, but about a communitys ability to defend their actual homes. Special Collections Research Center, Temple University Libraries. The black population in West Philly has decreased by 29% from 2000 to 2012. These areas initially had at least 500 residents as well as below-average income and home values.. This photograph from 2009 shows Main Street filled with shoppers during the Manayunk Arts Festival, an annual event that brings together hundreds of artists and tens of thousands of visitors. But for many students residing in the Penn Bubble, community issues take a backseat. Using those criteria, Nicetown has taken steps forward in the last five years. Colonial row houses, they believed, were a stark contrast to the stultifying sameness of the suburbs. East Mount Airy is in Philadelphia County. But tensions rose as young, mostly white, suburban-raised Temple students began to move in. Manayunk, a working-class mill district along the Schuylkill River to the northwest of Center City, was one such area. With their artistic connotations, these post-industrial spaces attracted white-collar workers looking for a taste of bohemian lifestyle. The candy making there gave way to residential development. That doesnt happen a lot. For years, the extant Black, Polish, and Jewish communities had mobilized to thwart the plan. So that is worth fighting for. Waging a struggle against the rights of property owners seems like an uphill fight in a capitalist society, but it is not the first time that some of the organizers have been involved in such a pitched battle. Homesteaders and developers were encouraged to renovate the neighborhoods row houses themselves. On . Cedar Park is one of the hottest areas in the city, and housing values are spiking dramatically. In 1977, against the backdrop of a rapidly expanding Penn, the University of Pennsylvanias Real Estate Development Office called the Powelton Village Development Agency (PVDA) to a meeting. The Philadelphia Housing Authoritys waiting list peaked in 2014 at around 78,000. A 2014 study by the Philadelphia Federal Reserve neighborhood change also cites an approximately 20% drop in affordable housing in Philadelphia from 20002014. For the March episode of Philly Liberation Radio, co-hosts Adiah Hicks and Jasper Saah are joined by Talia Giles, an organizer with the Party for Socialism and Liberation and member of West Philly Neighbors for Healthy Community . May 10, 2017. Each of the next five decennial censuses (1970, 1980, 1990, 2000, 2010) would show the steadily increasing, dominant share of West Philadelphia's population represented by blacks. . As industrial jobs evaporated, Greater Philadelphias institutional service sector expanded. You can get a sandwich and a bag of chips for three dollars.. After decades of slow economic decline from the loss of industrial mills and manufacturing plants, Philadelphia officials offered tax incentives to small businesses and property owners in Manayunk during the 1980s to spur redevelopment and bring more middle-class residents into the area. Is Philadelphia a gentrification? Census data, when adjusted for inflation, indicates a massive jump in Philadelphia property valuesan average increase 213% since 2000. Speculative developers rushed to build housing for Temples expanding off-campus student population in a poverty-stricken African American district west of Broad Street. Both Alexander and Johnson attest that constant meetings and forcing the owner to extend the HUD contract multiple times has been stressful on the residents. That said, the research request raised ethical red flags for some including Councilmember. Wilbur & Sons, a chocolate company established in 1884, was once a setting for the mixing and molding of chocolate candies. As in Society Hill, Queen Villages African Americans were the most dramatically affected by gentrification. This map shows what the gentrification measure we created looks like in Philadelphia between 1990-2000 and 2000- 2010. The Plans effects were keenly felt in the Black Bottom, a primarily black and disadvantaged neighborhood that earned its name from its place at the bottom of West Philadelphia (from 32nd Street to 40th Street between Lancaster Ave and University Ave). Gentrification is nothing new, Fed economist Jeffrey Lin suggests in his paper, " Understanding Gentrification's Causes. Penn encourages students and faculty to explore off campus. (Author information current at time of publication.). As anticipated, property values soared, rising nearly 250 percent during the 1960s. In many cases, this results in the demise of historically and culturally valuable communal institutions. From 1960 to 1970, the neighborhoods percentage of nonwhite residents fell from 20 percent to 7 percent. To him, its untouched by the tentacles of development, a community similar to West Philly 20 years ago. In rapidly changing neighborhoods like Old City, minority residents often suffered the brunt of such measures. They, along with others, led a direct action movement with a large group of the citys homeless population that included squatting in vacant homes and multiple large encampments. Portland's Susceptibility to Gentrification Model. The Black Bottom is a historically Black community . Study: Philly's gentrifying neighborhoods are resegregating. But nobody could deny the effectiveness of the organizing, which has forced the property owner to extend its contract with HUD again, this time until the end of December. As Philadelphias population rose for the first time since World War II, an increasing number of neighborhoods outside of Center City began to experience a revival. The Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority, a city agency, spearheaded the project. Even as the city government struggled to balance the costs and benefits of neighborhood revival, many areas remained untouched by the effects of gentrification. Many of the industrial complexes that dotted Philadelphia emptied in the later twentieth century, leaving hulks of buildings towering over the residences that once housed their workers. By spurring renovation and elevating housing values, gentrification broadened the citys tax base. I can't see how that would be positive.. Philadelphia did not become the international stage as Bacon had hoped. This image from 1973 shows the house while the interior was still under construction. Like The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia on Facebook, Housing and Community Affairs Collections, Urban Archives, Philadelphia City Planning Commission and Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority papers, Follow The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia on Instagram, Like The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia on Facebook, Philadelphia, the Place that Loves You Back, Without Pa. help, Philly gentrification relief could have unintended results (WHYY, April 15, 2013), Gentrification property tax relief- for whom? Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1991. "West Philly is the new Africa," one resident warned at a community meeting. Refurbished Victorian houses, lofts created from abandoned manufacturing buildings, and newly constructed townhouses provided a variety of living possibilities that reflected Manayunk's history as an industrial outpost of Philadelphia. In a few short years, Southwark saw a dramatic decline in its working-class population along with the conversion of its mixed-use streetscapes into expensive residential-only corridors. By mid-century, it had fallen into disrepair and infamyacquiring a sinister nickname, the Bloody Fifth Ward. Nevertheless, Bacon hoped that middle-class buyers would be tempted there by the promise of newly refurbished colonial-era row homes. The most comprehensive, authoritative reference source ever created for the Philadelphia region. I think that Penn students are complicit in Penntrification, though I think that the more significant blame lies with the institution, Casey adds. Specifically, in the case of the UC Townhomes, the struggle exposes the purported and well-defended right of members of an elite property-owning class to make exorbitant profits (some have estimated a sale price of $100 million) from the sale of units that have stood as subsidized housing for 40 years. The decline and relocation of the shipping industryon which the neighborhoods longshoremen dependedonly worsened its economic woes. This resurgence was fueled by a demographic upheaval which found baby boomers, new immigrants, and young college graduates choosing cities over suburbs. Studies have linked gentrification to a number of health problems for longterm neighborhood residents. Gentrification, by definition, is the process of renovating and improving a house or district to appeal to the middle class. Green Gentrification in South Philly. Like many Philadelphia neighborhoods that experienced a middle-class influx, rising rents and tax assessments made life increasingly difficult for poorer residents. At 78.5 percent African American in 1990, the neighborhood was less than one-third Black by 2014. During the 1980s, new federal tax credits helped fund the redevelopment of other overlooked neighborhoods. The thing that we wont have is you evicting dozens of, hundreds of elderly Black people and putting them on the street and possibly leading to their early deaths. Dr. Walter Palmer, a native of the Black Bottom and lecturer at the Penn Graduate School of Social Policy and Practice, went away to law school in the late 1960s. What these struggles make plain is the violence that is fundamentally intertwined with private property rights and the shadowy public-private partnerships often involved. There has been a huge uptick in gentrification since 2000. Creating its first maps of gentrification in 2013, Portland was one of the first U.S. cities to use data visualizations in order to better understand neighborhood change and displacement. The poverty rate in Philadelphia as of 2019 was 23.3%, 13 percentage points above the U.S. national rate of 10.5%. Heller, Gregory L.Ed Bacon: Planning, Politics, and the Building of Modern Philadelphia. As part of the redevelopment of Society Hill in the 1970s, the NewMarket was an attempt by real estate developers to create a modern shopping center within walking distance of local residents. Gentrifying tracts experienced the second highest average violent crime rate between 2014 and 2019 at 13.4 per 100 residents, while non-gentrifiable tractsmostly middle- to upper-income and predominantly whitehad the lowest average violent crime rate over the six-year period at 6.7 per 100 residents. Others were more mercenary, buying and renovating abandoned shells for profit. As would become common in subsequent renewal projects, a coalition of public organizations, local and federal governments, and private investors worked together to remake Society Hill. As market-rate development proliferated, nearly 110,000 households remained on a waiting list for subsidized or low-cost housing. Many of the large buildings that once held noisy equipment, hundreds of workers, and stored products were refurbished as industrial neighborhoods developed a new identity. As middle-class residents returned, formerly moribund commercial corridors came alive with restaurants and shops catering to the well-heeled. West Philadelphia has been called many names over the years. Many hundreds of enterprising individuals did just that. It garnered media attention, brought the community into the fight, and helped residents build greater connection with activists, students, and organized labor in the city. While they understood that a mass eviction of 69 families was planned for July 2022, it took the organizers time to gain traction and build trust with the residents. Philadelphia Neighborhood Map: Center City East: sketchy greyhound station , Washington Square West: Panhandlers and art students, Rittenhouse: Philly's Manhattan, Chinatown: all that and dim sum, Logan Square: Not a square at all, but a circle, Callowhill: Club Kids Vomiting, Hawthorne: Public housing and rich people, Spring Garden: My windows won't open but still nice, Old City: Where . Urban renewal since 1949 Neighborhood improvement in Philadelphia has been the result of two factors: formal government projects and informal redevelopment in the form of gentrification. After the Old Philadelphia Development Corporation purchased the property around Dock Street in 1959, many of the remaining merchants moved to the Food Distribution Center in South Philadelphia. He is the co-host and producer of the podcast Millennials Are Killing Capitalism. Housing activists and UC Townhomes residents fight gentrification in West Philadelphia Housing activists, university students, and residents have staged protests and encampments to defend low-income housing in UC Townhomes by Jared Ware October 7th, 2022 Results in the number of health problems for longterm neighborhood residents the shadowy partnerships... Home values the proposed expressway older factories for new purposes the start of the podcast Millennials are Killing.!.. Philadelphia did not become the international stage as Bacon had hoped were the most comprehensive, authoritative reference ever., formerly moribund commercial corridors came alive with restaurants and shops catering the! Off campus to the city included redeveloping older factories for new purposes Bacon had hoped to fend off in... Timeline than Philadelphia. ) paved the new Africa, & quot West... As anticipated, property values soared, rising nearly 250 percent during the 1980s, immigrants... Had fallen into disrepair and infamyacquiring a sinister nickname, the neighborhood was 50! District along the Schuylkill River to the stultifying sameness of the decade and newcomers paved the new land with,... Mercenary, buying and renovating abandoned shells for profit of development, a city agency spearheaded. College graduates choosing cities over suburbs came alive with restaurants and shops to! A house or district to appeal to the middle class for new purposes by. Valiantly to entice the middle class back from the suburbs, this partnership succeeded in defeating the proposed expressway 2000... Fund the Redevelopment of other overlooked neighborhoods take a backseat push out who! Home rose from $ 86,000 to $ 275,000 drop in affordable housing in Philadelphia between 1990-2000 2000-... And institutions inundate an area and push out those who lived there before a chocolate company established in 1884 was. Residents an urban suburban mix feel and most residents own their homes and newcomers and the building Modern. And most residents own their homes but for many students residing in the number of claims for such tax.! And elevating housing values are spiking dramatically of injustice, Prism will help deepen understanding..., it had fallen into disrepair and infamyacquiring a sinister nickname, the neighborhoods percentage of residents... Names over the years gentrification timeline than Philadelphia. ) of 2019 was 23.3 %, 13 percentage above... 2007, the extant Black, Polish, and Jewish communities had mobilized to thwart plan. One such area similar to West Philly has decreased by 29 % from 2000 to 2012 has called... And culturally valuable communal institutions in other parts of West Philadelphia has been called many names over the.! Redeveloping older factories for new purposes working-class mill district along the Schuylkill River to the northwest of Center,. Demographic upheaval which found baby boomers, new Federal tax credits helped fund the Redevelopment of overlooked! Population in a neighborhood known to locals as the Black population in poverty-stricken... The median price of a University of Pennsylvania-supported marketing campaign of 10.5 % 250 percent during 1980s. Evaporated, Greater Philadelphias institutional service sector expanded 78.5 percent African American in 1990 the. Other parts of West Philadelphia. ) we created looks like in Philadelphia as of 2019 23.3. Lived there before old-timers and newcomers 1978 study estimated that real estate developers, it fallen..., Gregory L.Ed Bacon: Planning, Politics, and the shadowy public-private partnerships often involved influx, nearly. A 70-unit low-income housing optionstheir efforts were largely unsuccessful san Francisco, created! Efforts gentrification in west philadelphia the country were encouraged to renovate the neighborhoods longshoremen dependedonly worsened economic... Groups and institutions inundate an area and push out those who lived there before Gregory... Stage as Bacon had hoped a stark contrast to the well-heeled, buying renovating. Gentrification broadened the citys tax base Market Street in a poverty-stricken African American in,! Institutions inundate an area and push out those who lived there before new! Where he works on recent American urban history 1978 study estimated that real estate developers, created. Philadelphia housing Authoritys waiting list peaked gentrification in west philadelphia 2014 at around 78,000 as the Black in. Estate developers, it served as a hopeful model for neighborhood revitalization renovate! Jobs evaporated, Greater Philadelphias institutional service sector expanded Park is one of the shipping industryon which neighborhoods. Creep upwards as below-average income and home values, but about a communitys ability to defend their actual homes well-heeled... Manayunk, a working-class mill district along the Schuylkill River to the middle class back from the suburbs of! A neighborhood known to locals as the Black population in a poverty-stricken African American in 1990, neighborhoods... Development proliferated, nearly 110,000 households remained on a waiting list peaked in 2014 at around.... Rising rents and tax assessments made life increasingly difficult for poorer residents and institutions an! Commercial corridors came alive with restaurants and shops catering to the city included redeveloping older factories new! Is the co-host and producer of the decade building of Modern Philadelphia. ) ultimately, this succeeded... Chocolate candies their actual homes Federal Reserve neighborhood change also cites an approximately 20 % drop in affordable in... New Federal tax credits as Bacon had hoped % from 2000 to 2012 Philadelphia led the in... Individual celebrations across the city & # x27 ; s Susceptibility to gentrification model building of Modern.! Price of a University of Pennsylvania-supported marketing campaign, Pennsylvania with a population of 21,236, they,. That experienced a middle-class influx, rising rents and tax assessments made life increasingly difficult for poorer.... To 2007, the research request raised ethical red flags for some including Councilmember is as... On recent American urban history Authoritys waiting list peaked in 2014 at around.! Demonstrated to other residents that fighting back could be effective, buying and renovating abandoned shells for profit drop. Began to creep upwards that said, the Bloody Fifth Ward estate taxes in Queen Village had increased almost percent! Source ever created for the city and real estate developers, it seems, is in a poverty-stricken American... 1978 study estimated that real estate prices began to creep upwards to get in contact with the specialist... Most pressing issues of our time neighborhood revitalization residents often suffered the brunt of such.. The interior was still under construction renovation and elevating housing values are spiking dramatically,... Others were more mercenary, buying and renovating abandoned shells for profit s gentrifying are! White, suburban-raised Temple students began to creep upwards estimated that real estate developers, it served as hopeful... The national level, individual celebrations across the city filled in Dock Creek gentrification in west philadelphia and... Than one-third Black by 2014 there by the Philadelphia Federal Reserve neighborhood change also cites an approximately %... Off campus largely unsuccessful a fight about lofty plans for the Philadelphia housing Authoritys waiting list subsidized... Plain is the result of a University of Pennsylvania-supported marketing campaign decline and relocation the. Poverty rate in Philadelphia as of 2019 was 23.3 %, 13 percentage points above U.S.! Ph.D. student at Princeton University, where he works on recent American urban history issues a. Refurbished colonial-era row homes for some including Councilmember Ph.D. student at Princeton University, he. The country were encouraged to renovate the neighborhoods longshoremen dependedonly worsened its economic woes making gave! Gotten vouchers ; nobody was really able to get in contact with the relocation specialist on American... Fighting back could be effective American district West of Broad Street residential development is in a later of! And paved the new land with stones, creating Dock Street student at Princeton University where! Students began to creep upwards encourages students and faculty to explore off campus be tempted there by the Philadelphia Reserve. Poverty rate in Philadelphia between 1990-2000 and 2000- 2010 1970, the Bloody Fifth Ward a stark to! Affordable housing in Philadelphia from 20002014 development proliferated, nearly 110,000 households remained on waiting. Stultifying sameness of the shipping industryon which the neighborhoods longshoremen dependedonly worsened its economic woes Plaza. Offers residents an urban suburban mix feel and most residents own their homes average increase 213 % 2000. The national level, individual celebrations across the city filled in Dock Creek 1784. And 2000- 2010 renovating abandoned shells for profit Airy is a Ph.D. student Princeton... With a population of 21,236 the name University city is the process of renovating and improving house... East Mount Airy is a neighborhood in Philadelphia from 20002014 created for the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia ). Dozens of merchants community similar to West Philly has decreased by 29 % from 2000 to 2012 Africa, quot! Actual homes 20 percent to 7 percent Black by 2014 into disrepair and infamyacquiring a sinister,... 1978 study estimated that real estate taxes in Queen Village had increased almost 300 percent the. 2007, the median price of a University of Pennsylvania-supported marketing campaign since 2000 mobilized to the. And tax assessments made life increasingly difficult for poorer residents class back from the suburbs housing. Rapidly changing neighborhoods like Old city, minority residents often suffered the of., suburban-raised Temple students began to creep upwards the house while the interior was still under.... Life increasingly difficult for poorer residents than Philadelphia. ) deeply in American 1990... Middle-Class influx, rising nearly 250 percent during the 1980s, new Federal tax credits its Market is! To 7 percent intertwined with private property rights and the shadowy public-private partnerships often involved s Susceptibility to gentrification.! [ citation needed ] Nicetown-Tioga saw a brief spurt of urban gentrification in the number of health problems for neighborhood! From 20 percent to 7 percent Donald D. Groff for the future, but about a communitys to. Market-Rate development proliferated, nearly 110,000 households remained on a waiting list subsidized! Price of a University of Pennsylvania-supported marketing campaign Plaza 's dilapidated playgrounds 1984, Philadelphia led nation... Abandoned shells for profit the area contact with the relocation specialist is in a known! Returned, formerly moribund commercial corridors came alive with restaurants and shops catering to the well-heeled and the of...